Mickey Mantle, Martial Artist

The Great Mickey Mantle

Mickey Mantle was a legendary baseball player, and I think there are lessons from his life that martial artists should learn.

Mantle was a switch hitter, meaning that he could bat both right-handed as well as left-handed, and typically batted left-handed. Although Mantle thought of himself as a better right-handed hitter, he actually hit more home runs left-handed. Some think that Mantle hit more left-handed home runs because the right field fence in Yankee Stadium was closer than the center and left field fences, but I have another theory.

In Big Stick Combat I teach you to hold the stick as though you are batting left handed. I just read Ted Williams book on hitting, and he argues that having your dominant hand as the upper hand results in greater power. I disagree. I know –who am I to disagree with Ted Williams?

But could the weaker hand on the bottom be a convention that isn’t true? Many former truths have been re-examined. When the first high jumper did the Fosbury Flop and jumped over the bar backwards, everyone knew he was doing it all wrong. In time, though, athletes recognized the superiority of his technique.

When you swing a bat, the hand near the pommel is the dominant hand, which is stronger because it pulls the bat through the swing, while the upper hand is less effective because it pushes. If your stronger, dominant hand grips near the pommel of he bat, you will hit harder. Perhaps this explains Mantle’s greater number of left-handed home runs, as well as his bat swing, which was called “ferocious.” (Mantle also practiced batting left-handed from a young age.)

A critical component of hitting power is speed. Mantle alluded to this fact when he said “If you swing for distance, you almost have to have the bat in motion before the pitch is even released.” So not only did Mantle have a fast swing, but he accelerated quickly. The ability to explosively whip the bat forward at great velocity not only enables you to hit hard, but to get the jump on the opponent.

Consider the following quote of Mickey Mantle: “Stan Musial and Ted Williams were both every bit as strong as I am. The difference is that they were always trying to meet the ball, while I always wanted to kill it.”

I believe the martial artist needs to have the same attitude as Mickey’s, not to hit the opponent, but to obliterate him. The mindset of Mantle’s is one of total effort and commitment to crushing the opponent, which in his case was a baseball. When I studied Tapado with GM Vasquez, I was surprised to learn that the system has no feints, no set-up strikes, and no moves designed to lure or draw the opponent. Every strike in Tapado is all-out in the most direct line.

Combat is not just a matter of learning techniques, but learning a new way of thinking. It takes courage to commit yourself totally. As Mantle said, “When you keep aiming for the fences, you’re bound to strike out a lot.” Often a fear of failure, of losing, of getting hit, or getting hurt, makes us hesitate, and use half measures.

Fearlessness and total commitment are valuable lessons for all of us, both in combat and in our daily lives.


3 Responses to “Mickey Mantle, Martial Artist”

  1. Dwight U. Phillips Says:

    I enjoy your analysis.

  2. Mick hit more homers left handed because there were and are more right handed pitchers which gave him many more opportunities to hit them from the left side. Most of his truly tape measure homers were hit from the right side and when he participated in home run competition with Killebrew he batted right handed. He was an authentic long ball hitter.

    • Marty,

      Thanks for sharing. I just thought I’d offer an idea like the “Fosbury Flop,” in which the high jumper leaped with his back over the bar. Although it seemed totally wrong, it eventually became standard technique. I argue that for a right-hander, the right hand at the pommel and the left above it is stronger.

      Please note that I’ve moved to my new blog, BigStickCombat.com

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s